Direct instructions or didactic teaching has been around for centuries and few tried to question this paradigm. Traditionally, lectures are always followed by some types of questions or assessments and students seem comfortable with this status quo. But what happens when students are presented with an ill-structured problem or question they don't know the answer to yet? Can it improve students understanding and knowledge application?
Manu Kapur, the creator of Productive Failure theory certainly thinks so. Kapur’s Productive Failure draws on constructivist and generative views of learning: learners actively build understanding by engaging with ideas, rather than simply receiving explanations. They first attempt a challenging, unfamiliar problem, generating and comparing possible solutions that activate and reveal the limits of their prior knowledge. This struggle is intended to prepare learners to notice and make sense of key concepts when the teacher subsequently consolidates their ideas and provides explicit instruction. The sequence also reflects conceptual change: learners can compare their initial intuitions with more disciplinary ways of reasoning, reorganise their understanding, and apply it to new problems. In this way, failure is productive when it is followed by carefully designed teaching that turns students’ attempts into resources for deeper conceptual understanding and transfer.
The tutorial begins with a complex clinical-scientific problem before students have been given a complete explanatory framework. Teams draw on prior knowledge to summarise and illustrate the mechanisms of atherosclerosis and the role of chronic inflammation in it. Additionally, they are posed with a question of possible solution to this problem, i.e. which pathways could be targeted by novel therapies. This not only challenges students prior knowledge but also makes their assumptions of mechanisms and interventions visible.
Tutors then guide a consolidation phase in which students compare their initial ideas with the relevant concepts, correct misconceptions and refine their explanations. This sequence uses the productive struggle to prepare students for new learning and helps them practise the transfer of pathology knowledge to unfamiliar scenarios.
The approach was adopted after ANZAHPE 2024 conference and discussion with Dr Naomi Steenhof.
Students feedback:
Of 38 students who completed the questionnaire, 94.7% agreed the session was interactive and engaging; 92.1% reported improved skills and understanding.